Mandi’s Kitchen Renovation Reveal

rustic modern kitchen renovationLast April, I had the amazing experience of selling our old home just seven days after getting the crazy idea that we should move to a new house. Finding a mint mid-century home with a sunken conversation pit—in your price range—will do that to a girl! To say it was a whirlwind week would be an understatement! I remember feeling heartbroken the night we signed papers with the buyer because we discovered the dream home which launched this crazy scheme was already under contract with another buyer. But man, was I excited that we had just sold our house so quickly! … And of course I was also a little worried about being homeless and living with my parents indefinitely.

I sat at my computer scrolling through the many homes I’d seen and checked out before. Nice. But lots of work. Or else absolutely perfect, but too much money. Finally, out of desperation, I clicked on an odd looking ’80s home I’d scrolled past lots of times, and was surprised when the wheels in my head starting turning. Nay, spinning! I couldn’t stop looking at this kitchen, imagining all of the things I could fairly easily change. I was intrigued and booked an appointment to view the home the next day.

After viewing the house, we were surprised at how perfectly it fit all of our family’s peculiar needs, so we made an offer, and I went back to the house to take measurements to put on AutoCAD after our offer was accepted. Yes, I am the psycho who had detailed drawings, to-scale plans, and budget sheets made up before we even closed on the house! I thought it would be fun to show you the initial kitchen drawing I made back then, and if you’re curious, you can see more of my kitchen plans and process on my blog here, here, here, and here.

mandi's kitchen before

kitchen planningrustic modern kitchen renovationSurprisingly, not many details changed from the ideas that had popped into my head that night that I viewed the home online for the first time. For budget reasons, I wanted to reuse as much from the original kitchen as possible, and because I was not a fan of the oak raised panel cabinetry, painting the cabinets white would allow them to fade to the background and not make much of a design statement. I also wanted to make the space feel much airier, so I decided to remove all of the upper cabinets completely, and only replace them with a single row of open shelving. As far as storage goes, I had plenty of cabinets left in the island and below the countertops (the lazy susan in the corner is amazing!). The cabinet I built above the fridge as well as the wall of shelving gave me the rest of the storage I needed. (Oh, and there’s a pantry closet behind the shelving wall.)

Because most of the kitchen would be white, I wanted to make sure there were plenty of texturally interesting things, but not in a cluttered way. The wide-open wall above the cabinets was the perfect place to add texture! I covered it completely with wide subway tiles, choosing a stackbond pattern to feel more contemporary than your average white subway tile wall. I agonized over what grout color to use and am really happy with the TEC Silverado grout, because it adds definition between the tiles without too much contrast. There’s also a lot of texture thanks to my open shelving. Everything on the shelves is white or glass, so the shelving doesn’t feel cluttered, yet there’s still interest there. All of the clean white is juxtaposed with some rustic wood elements, like the huge wall of shelving I built, and a vintage spice rack that repeats the style of the shelving wall. A wooden butcherblock countertop from Lumber Liquidators, wooden cabinet knobs, wooden stools, and wicker baskets all work together to add warmth, balancing out the stark coldness of white everywhere.

mandi's kitchen duringLiterally the day we closed on the house, Phil and I began demo! I pulled out all of the carpet on the first floor, and for a date night, Phil and I busted out and removed all of the tile from the kitchen and hallway. Talk about romantic! Then my dad helped take off the old countertop and separate all of the cabinets. We reconfigured them so we could move the stove to a different wall, making more space for a main dining area in the eat-in kitchen. (We are using the formal dining room as a play room.)

Once everything was cleaned out, and the cabinets were positioned, it was so exciting to rebuild! My favorite project that I took on by myself was the shelving wall. I may add some rustic doors to parts of this shelving wall in the days to come, but I sure do love having easy access to dry goods and snacks, plus, who am I kidding? I love stuff, and these shelves let me rearrange my stuff in fun ways with each change of seasons.

KitchenAid Commercial Gas RangeThe most exciting day of the rebuilding has to be the day my new stove was installed! I had only ever dreamed of owning such a beauty—six burners, dual-heat steam oven … forget about it. I love all of our new appliances, but this stove makes it easier for me to get out of bed in the morning. (Especially if I have ingredients for pancakes, bacon, and eggs in the fridge!) I still pinch myself every day I get to use this bad boy. I also am so glad we moved its location to this other wall. Our old stove was electric, so we had to run gas lines anyway, we may as well move the stove to a more convenient spot. Rerouting the exhaust vent wasn’t bad because the joists in the ceiling happened to run parallel with the stove wall. We plugged up the hole from the old vent with ventilation and covered it on the inside with drywall and tile, and covered the hole on the exterior with a metal plate and silicon until we’re able to patch the siding.

organized pantry jarsPeople often ask about the jars I use to store my food. They are Le Parfait brand, and you can find them lots of places online, but I’ve also had luck finding them at discount home stores such as Marshalls and HomeGoods. I used to have labels on every jar, but now I only have them on certain necessary ones that are easily mixed up. (Once I tried to make frosting using baking soda instead of powdered sugar!) I’m frequently moving the contents of a barely filled jar into a smaller one to free up the big jars, so things get shuffled around and labels just get to be annoying in that instance.

organized pantry jarsMy girls and I begin every morning at the kitchen island. I sip coffee and answer their crazy questions while they usually eat eggs and toast or fruit and yogurt. We usually have lunch at the counter, too, but dinners happen at the round antique table that I scored on Craigslist. It has three leaves, so we can make it bigger for when we’re hosting friends and family, but most of the time it stays small like this.

Antique pedestal table with modern tulip chairsI carried the traditional-rustic-meets-minimal-modern vibes to the dining area where I use the antique table alongside these elegant Lippa chairs from LexMod. The vintage booster seat gives this spot the perfect mix of old and new.

I sort of freaked out with excitement when I found this beautiful chandelier from Hinkley Lighting, because it so perfectly mixes a variety of styles I love: Bauhaus-inspired shiny chrome, funky ’70s curves and globe shapes, understated elegance that feels a bit traditional … Oh, and the clincher was that there were matching pendants perfectly sized for our kitchen island!

pink kitchen sink by ThermocastI can’t believe I’ve come this far without acknowledging my pink sink. I chose most of the materials because their were inexpensive and because they were safe enough that I knew I’d be happy with them for years to come. But I had to have a little fun somewhere! That’s where the pink sink comes in. This is an acrylic sink by Thermocast which is undermounted beneath our white Corian counters for the perfect pop of pink. I use a tray in the bottom of the sink to keep it from getting scratched up, but also to conveniently rinse dishes when things get piled up.Legrand Radiant Dimmer Paddle SwitchWith all of the new materials, I hadn’t considered how junky our old outlets and switches would be until I saw them alongside the new white walls and tile. Ugh. Details matter! So we installed new paddle switches, universal dimmers, and outlets from the Legrand Radiant line. The screwless wall plates are the perfect finishing touch and just fade to the background, letting my design choices take center stage. We also installed outlets with built-in nightlights in our halls and pathways, so we can easily sneak into the kitchen for midnight snacks!

rustic modern kitchen renovationrustic modern shelf vignettelexmod lippa chairs with antique tableChoosing a shade of white for our walls was a little stressful (even though I wrote an entire blog post about choosing white paint!), but I’m happy with Benjamin Moore’s Super White in our kitchen. It’s a particularly tricky space because there are a lot of white I don’t have control over, shade-wise, like our KitchenAid appliances, the dining chairs, the tiles, and to some extent, the countertops. Super White ended up being the perfect neutral white for this environment (not cool or warm) that felt very bright, but not as stark as untinted white would feel. It feels bright, crisp, and modern— perfectly at peace with the other white elements in the kitchen.

legrand radiant GFCI outletsrustic modern kitchen renovationIf you’d like to check out some of my older posts that chronicle my kitchen planning and process, I’ve listed them out for you below. You can also see a list of products and materials I used at the end of this post! If you have any questions, I’m more than happy to talk shop in the comments section.

Thanks so much for following along on this adventure! This has been the biggest home reno undertaking I’ve attempted, and I’m really happy with the results. Now I can’t wait to get started on some other rooms in our house! –Mandi

rustic modern dining roomMaterials and Products:

Wall paint: Benjamin Moore’s Super White
Cabinet paint: Annie Sloan’s Pure White (not on hood vent or refrigerator cabinet)
Wall tile: Home Depot
Tile grout: TEC Silverado
Outlets and switches: Legrand Radiant
Pink sink: Thermocast
Faucet: Kraus from Home Depot
Island butcher block: Lumber Liquidators sealed with Waterlox
Flooring: Lumber Liquidators maple engineered wood
Knobs: eBay
Stove: KitchenAid from Home Depot
Hood vent: Whirlpool from Home Depot with DIY cover
Dishwasher: KitchenAid from Home Depot
Refrigerator: KitchenAid from HomeDepot
Coffee maker: KitchenAid
Bar stools: Sold out at Target— similar here
Dining chairs: LexMod
Art: Milton Avery reproduction
Round lidded baskets on shelving wall: Xinh & Co
Kitchen radio: TEAC
Lighting: Hinkley Congress collection 
Food storage jars: Le Parfait
Bread boxes: Amazon – small and large
Rug, spice rack, utensil crocks, dining table, booster seat, various pottery: vintage

Credits // Author and Photography: Mandi Johnson. Photos edited with A Color Story Desktop.
  • I am not normally a huge fan of doing all white in kitchens, just because it can get super messy, kind of like owning a white vehicle lol! But aside from my opinion, you did a wonderful job! I love the accent countertop/butcher block island and the shelving. Great for organizing with having to open any doors! Again, very impressed with the outcome!

  • Beautiful! Would you mind sharing the size of the tiles? I’m thinking of doing a stacked subway tile like this with 3×12” tiles. Most photos I see of stacked bond are smaller size tiles but I think these may be closer to 3×12” and they work wonderfully in the space!

  • I love how you renovated your kitchen. White color and huge windows are my weakness when it comes to kitchen. Also the rug in your kitchen looks really nice.

  • Hi Mandi, I love your kitchen, and the drawings you made. Your kitchen layout is almost exactly the same as mine, and I was wondering if you could tell me the width and length of your main kitchen space. I worry that what I’m putting in might feel cramped, and what I’m putting in is nearly identical to what you have, so I would really appreciate it. Thanks! (I live sort of near you, too! Holmes County.)

  • Hi Mandi! I love your renovation. Can you please tell me where I may purchase the barstools? They are exactly what I’m looking for. Thank you !!

  • Amazing makeover idea I just love it, if you are finding kitchen designers in atlanta I recommended Berkeley Woodworking, Inc. As my own experience says that you will get your dream kitchen

  • Love your kitchen remodel Mandi. Those wood shelves are gorgeous and your new stove must be a dream 🙂

  • I love the wooden top on the island. It is very helpful and informative. I just wished I can try it also to my kitchen.
    Home and Kitchen Improvement
    Kitchen Tools
    Kitchen Renovation
    Kitchen Design

  • The wooden top on the island is beautiful and I love the level of organisation with the jars! Lovely light and airy too!

  • Hello
    Is it possible to know how much roughly did this renovation cost? I have a very similar kitchen (your before) and would really like to remodel the same way you did.

  • I love every single thing in your kitchen! It really turned out beautifully. Could you please share what type of wood your countertop is made of? I am also considering a Lumber Liquidators counter and am wondering how much it will darken in color after applying Waterlox. Thank you in advance!

  • WOW! That’s all I can say. You guys did one hell of a job; I wish I could go for open cabinetry in my kitchen, but with 3 cats who like to knock things over and get into the cabinets as is… That’s just a pipe dream. They style you went for looks wonderful in your home, though! Such a unique take on cabinetry.

  • Anyone who puts a Milton Avery reproduction in their kitchen wins my heart. My favorite!

  • Hi mandi!! Could you give me a hand with a pink thermocast sink?? I am a designer and am remodeling in panama, central america, and there s no way i cld get ahold of more pics or images of this pink and Thermocast NEVER pick up their phone!!!! Any chance you could tell me if you liked the sink and it worked out, scratched? etc etc send 1000 Thanks in advance, sara

  • Beautiful! I love white with wood and its so clever how you used what you could from the old kitchen, but it all looks fresh and new 🙂

  • I love how her space turned out! It is beautiful!


  • Wow, what a transformation! It’s so much brighter now, and those kitchen shelves look amazing!

  • WOW – I love the subway tiles to the ceiling and I LOVE the pink sink! It’s true – the smallest details make the biggest difference! Awesome transformation!

  • Hello! I just spent my lunch hour gushing over your kitchen reno on your blog. I too have an interior design degree (with minors in graphic design and construction), and my hubby and I are renovating our first home. I’m in awe of your Photoshop renderings (I’ve never rendered using PS) and you are so inspiring me 🙂

    Would you mind sharing the dimensions of your island, including how much it overhangs? We are planning a butcher block island with a 12″ overhang, and we’ve been questioning whether or not to add corbels underneath for strength.

    Thanks in advance! You have a beautiful space 🙂

    • Thanks for your sweet words! I used the standard island countertop that Lumber Liquidators had in stock and didn’t need to cut it down or add to it at all! It was a big relief, because we did quite a bit of work with butcher block joinery and whatnot in our old home. The overhang is 10″ and feels perfect.

  • I’ve been obsessed with following this reno on Instagram, and I can’t wait to see what you do with the other parts of the house, Mandi! This may be a silly question, but did you hang the two little frames on your kitchen tile with Command strips, or something similar? I’m renting now, but I can’t wait to buy my own house someday!

  • This looks awesome! I’m in the process of buying a fixer upper and redoing the entire kitchen, something just like you’ve done here! I love the light colors! Is there any chance you’d be willing to share a little bit about our budget and where you cut costs? I’m lost in all the numbers and would love insight from someone who’s kitchen turned out so beautifully!

    • I cut cost primarily by reusing existing cabinets (I rearranged them, painted them, and swapped out hardware) and also with the countertop, tile, and flooring materials. My countertops on the main counters are Corian, and the island is butcher block. Both lower end materials, but not as inexpensive as laminate. Also I chose subway tiles because they were the most affordable yet nice looking tiles that fit the look I wanted. My flooring was lower end engineered wood from Lumber Liquidators, which wasn’t my first choice, but saved me a ton on flooring. I had planned on buying nice appliances on Craigslist to save money that way, but ended up being able to work with Home Depot on appliances, which was a dream for me! Hope that’s helpful for you.

  • Love it! Very similar to my parents house layout for the kitchen.
    However I don’t think my dad would EVER go for the pink sink…. But it’s fun!

  • All of your renovations so far are beautifully done! The white countertops – can you provide a link or details on those?

    • They are Corian countertops that I had installed through The Home Depot. I forget the exact name of the white, but it’s the whitest white they have, and happens to be in their most affordable tier! 🙂

  • Wow! It looks amazing! I would love a kitchen like that, it is so cool to see the before, design layout, and after! xx

  • What an excellent job, Mandi! I’m jealous, I’d love to have your kitchen. Love the white space with the dark wood furnishings. Very natural. 🙂

    Charmaine Ng | Architecture & Lifestyle Blog

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.