Spooky Eye Cake Toppers

Spooky Eye Cake Toppers (click through for tutorial) One of my favorite things about Halloween is all the cute and creepy twists that people put on otherwise ordinary party foods. However, when you are the one that’s actually throwing the party, it’s always a big bonus if you can find a cute idea that only takes a few minutes to put together. If you’re doing a Halloween party this year, here’s a fast and easy way to make your own spooky eye cake toppers to really set off your dessert table.

Spooky Eye Cake Toppers (click through for tutorial) Supplies:
-Oreos (the Double Stuffed version gives you a bit more icing to keep the eyeballs in place)
mini Oreos
-thin wooden craft sticks
candy eyeballs

Spooky Eye Cake Toppers (click through for tutorial) Twist off the top of the Oreo so that you have one half remaining with the creme filling intact. Slide your craft stick about 2/3 of the way under the Oreo creme, and then press a candy eyeball firmly into the center of the creme.

Spooky Eye Cake Toppers (click through for tutorial) Repeat the process with a mini Oreo, but use a knife or small spoon to scrape away excess creme from around the edge of the eyeball candy so the eyeballs stand out a bit more. Place the skewers on a plate and place in the freezer for a few minutes to set the ingredients together.

Spooky Eye Cake Toppers (click through for tutorial) Place the skewers into the cake at different angles and heights, and your spooky cake is done!

Spooky Eye Cake Toppers (click through for tutorial) I love the playful cuteness of the eyeballs and the fact that all the different circles add a bit of geometric flare to the cake as well. The fun part is that you can also pull out the toppers as the cake gets eaten and they are totally edible as well (minus the stick of course!). And now don’t you see what I mean when I said it was an easy way to create a food decoration? xo. Laura

Credits // Author and Photography: Laura Gummerman. Photos edited with the NEW A Beautiful Mess actions.

  • Ohh I LOVE this! I recently had a pumpkin carving party and made salted caramel apple cupcakes but would have loved to see these cake toppers! Great idea.

  • This makes me so excited for Halloween, you have provided some great inspiration here! x

  • That’s such an amazing idea! I’m definitely gonna do that next week when my brothers come for dinner! I know the children are gonna love it.

  • It’s so impressive how you guys can make Halloween look chic. Keep up the great content!x

  • These are the cutest! So creative and sure to be a hit!

    Xx Taylor

  • That cake is so fun – I love the simple Halloween eyeball treats on top! And you’re right- super easy is best!

  • such a cute idea, and so simple!!!!


  • Your nails always look SO good, Laura! I’m always jealous of people with beautiful hands! hehe

  • You guys are so creative it’s unbelievable! I know I won’t be decorating any cakes in particular for this Halloween but wow, this idea is amazing! The result looks so cool, and bonus points ’cause it’s edible (yes Oreos yes) haha!
    Have a great week ahead xo

    Joanne | Life in Blue Skies

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.