Homemade Valentine’s Day Treat Boxes

Homemade Valentine Treat Boxes6 I love making fancy edible gifts, and receiving them, too! Valentine’s Day is a great chance to cure my holiday season baking withdrawals and get back into the kitchen to whip up some pretty treats. I have a habit of collecting baking accessories like some girls collect jewelry, and I recently purchased some alphabet cookie cutters and molds. I decided to put them to use for typographic Valentine’s Day treats, and with a quick paint job on these paper mache boxes, I had some nice little homemade treat boxes to give to my friends.

Homemade Valentine Treat BoxesAlphabet Brownies

-brownie batter
-non-stick cooking spray
alphabet mold
-paper mache box (I used a 7×7 box for the brownies and used these nesting boxes later.)
Gesso (or your desired paint)
-paint brush

Step One: I used an icing piping bag to fill select letters of my mold with brownie batter. (I cut the Q shaped brownie to make another U.) After baking the brownies in the mold until a toothpick inserted into the brownie comes out clean, I allowed them to cool. Then I put them in the freezer for a couple of hours to harden them. This made them less brittle, allowing me to easily pop each brownie letter out of the mold.

Step Two: While the brownies were in the oven, I began painting my paper mache boxes. I hand painted stripes with Gesso because gesso is thicker than paint and will be opaque after just one coat. I also used a paint dabber to make polka dots on another box. I painted the inside of the boxes with two coats of gesso.

Homemade Valentine Treat BoxesStep Three: I used square-shaped baking liners because they fit better into a square box to make a checked pattern. These liners are reusable silicone liners that you can actually bake right inside of if you’d prefer to just make mini cakes for your treat boxes.

Doesn’t it look fun? I lofted this top layer of brownies with a piece of card stock. You can fit another layer of treats below.

Homemade Valentine Treat BoxesHomemade Valentine Treat BoxesGlazed Mini Cakes

In addition to the alphabet brownies, I wanted to make XO petit fours, but the cookie cutters I used were just a bit large for petit fours. So in the end I guess I made mini cakes in the style of petit fours, with half of them glazed in poured fondant, and the other half glazed with a chocolate coating.

-pound cake
-marzipan or almond paste
-knife & alphabet cookie cutter

Poured Fondant:
-1/2 cup water
-2 1/2 cup sugar
-1/4 cup light corn syrup
-food coloring
-vanilla extract
-candy thermometer

Chocolate Glaze:
-dark chocolate chips
-coconut oil
(portions are dependent on your needs.)

Homemade Valentine Treat BoxesStep One: Cut pound cake into .75″ even slices.

Step Two: Cut out the pound cake into the Xs and Os using your alphabet cookie cutters.

Homemade Valentine Treat BoxesStep Three: Spread a thin layer of jam to make little sandwiches, stacking two layers of pound cake.

Step Four: Roll out the marzipan or almond paste into a thin sheet and cut out enough pieces to top each of the pound cake sandwiches you made. Wet one side of the marzipan or almond paste so it will adhere to the top of the sandwiches. This layer will allow for a smooth top when you glaze the cakes.

Refrigerate the finished sandwiches for at least two hours. This helps all of the layers to really come together. Make sure to cover the sandwiches or keep in an air-tight container.

Homemade Valentine Treat BoxesStep Five: Combine the sugar, water, and syrup in a pan to make the poured fondant. Stir until the mixture reaches the soft ball stage (which should be marked on your candy thermometer. Pour the syrup into a food processor and allow to cool to 140 degrees F.

Step Six: Add the coloring and vanilla extract to the syrup and process for 2-3 minutes. Transfer to a microwavable bowl suitable for dipping the cakes into the fondant.

Homemade Valentine Treat BoxesStep Seven: Dip the room temperature cakes into the fondant and place on a cooling rack. I had to microwave my fondant to get it back to a runny liquid state in between icing each cake.

Step Eight: Combine coconut oil and chocolate chips ( I used about 1/4 C coconut oil with 2 cups of chips, but probably could’ve used less oil.) Melt in the microwave or using a double broiler just until the chips are soft. Stir and microwave until the mixture is just melted. Dip the cakes, place onto a cooling rack, and chill in the refrigerator until the chocolate has set up.

Coconut oil melts at body temperature, so be careful when handling the chocolate glazed cakes.

Homemade Valentine Treat BoxesI lined a painted paper mache box with wax paper and place the cakes inside. They were a perfect fit in the largest these nesting boxes I had. Though a bit more time-intensive than regular glazed cakes, the petit four style of layering and glazing is so delectable. I can’t wait to make smaller versions, because I’m sure they are much easier to dip in the poured fondant. Brings me back to my American Girl tea party days!

Homemade Valentine Treat BoxesSo special, and even more delicious. The perfect little valentine surprise for someone you love. –Mandi

Credits // Author and Photography: Mandi Johnson. Photos edited with Stella and Valentine from the Signature Collection.

  • this is way too adorable! My god, I wish I was a baking expert.


  • Mmmmmm these look delicious!

  • Oh, yum yum yum! One can never go wrong with a gift like this!!!
    The Chronic Dreamer

  • handmade gifts are my favourite and all boxes seems so delcious that I am going to copy alls!!!

  • Awesome! Check out my amazing DIY Valentine’s Day Gift for your Valentine! http://theluxylife.com/

    Great post!

  • Such a cute idea!! I kinda want to make them as a gift to myself 🙂 haha okay I might share with my husband too


  • I really love that idea! Making treats and putting them perfectly on a box like that really makes them stand out. I’ll keep that idea in mind for Christmas presents also.

  • It’s true. Your blog is the best blog ever. I spent hours reading your posts, tips, glazing on ur pics… Thanks for all you’ve done for us and continue doing, guys!!! We appreciate it. I do.

  • They both taste good and look good. Can it even get better?


  • I love the silicone liners! And the XO cakes look so simple to make, definitely making these for V Day

  • Those alphabet molds are such a good investment. I like the silicone squares too because the person who gets this gift can re use them whenever they want.

    Monica – Mocha and Moccasins

  • I love the idea of enlarged petit fours! I can’t wait to try your recipe for our next party. Thanks for sharing!


  • I totally made petit fours in American Girls club growing up. (We actually had a weekly homeschool history club going through one of the girls’ history per year!) And my mom’s Valentine to my dad ever since I can remember was baking a pan of brownies and cutting a heart out of it – he got the outside because he loves the chewy edges 🙂 Yum!

  • So Cute! What a perfect idea. Cute and personal but simple!

  • These valentines are beautiful! I love the glazed x’s and o’s!

    Warm Regards,

  • This is a gift that shows some dedication! I hope that the receivers will realize that there has actually been put quite some effort into what seems like a sweet little thing. Nevertheless I would love to receive a treat like these! 🙂

  • These are great! I’m a big fan of chocolate/coconut oil shell. Works so well and gives the hint of a Mounds bar!


  • I love the idea 🙂
    very cute and something special and personal too
    great inspiration 😉

  • This is honest to God the cutest thing I have ever seen!!!

    xo, Becky

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.