Pumpkin Pie (in Jars!)

Pumpkin Pie in Jars! (click through for the full recipe)For the second dessert we served at Friendsgiving we went with pumpkin pie. I've always wanted to try baking pies in jars. It's a thing, have you seen? I loved the idea of making small, individual servings. It makes it feel like I made a dessert just for you. 🙂104Don't you just love pumpkin pie? It's one of my all time favorites. Mine have a thin pie crust on the bottom but you could also easily make these with a graham cracker crust if you prefer. Whatever you do don't forget to garnish with a little whipped cream (homemade or store-bought) or a small scoop of ice cream.100Pumpkin Pie (in Jars!), makes 10-12 small jars

16 oz. softened cream cheese
1/2 cup sugar
1/2 cup brown sugar
1 can (15 oz.) pumpkin puree
3 tablespoons flour
1 tablespoon milk
1 teaspoon ground cinnamon
1/4 teaspoon of each: ginger, nutmeg and cloves
3 eggs

Crusts are the same recipe as here

In a mixer with a whisk attachment, or by hand, blend together the cream cheese and sugars. Stir in the pumpkin, milk and eggs until smooth. Stir in the flour and spices. In a jar layer pie crusts, then 1 cup pie batter. You can add a small piece of pie crusts shaped like a pumpkin or fall leaf, if you're fancy like that.

Bake at 375°F for 30 minutes, just until it's set. Allow to cool before serving. Pumpkin Pie in Jars! (click through for the full recipe) These were fun! I enjoyed doing pumpkin pie just a little different this year. 🙂 xo. Emma

Credits // Author: Emma Chapman, Photos by: Janae Hardy

  • Hi Emma. Super delicious and what a simple hassle free dessert for Thanksgiving. We’ve shared your recipe in our latest Thanksgiving inspiration roundup https://craftylikegranny.com/thanksgiving-crafts/ Cheers Jodie 🙂

  • That is a great idea and it looks soooooo yummy! Mmm!


  • Made it for Thanksgiving, boyfriend snuck into the fridge while everyone was asleep and ate all of the leftovers…I think he liked it 😉

  • Please tell people to use oven proof jars!
    Some young/new cooks might not know that.

  • Yummy! The pumpkin pie looks delicious and so easy to make! The little jars are very cute.

    Carpet cleaners

  • This looks so easy! I might be making this for Thanksgiving. 🙂

  • Mine are just small canning jars from Wal-mart. The “Mainstay” brand I think, it’s the Wal-mart brand. 🙂

  • No, you can actually bake in glass. One thing to watch for though is you don’t want to go from hot to cold too quickly or it can cause the glass to crack. So, taking the hot jars from the oven and popping them in the refrigerator is not the best idea. Allow them to cool first. Good luck!

  • These are so cute!!! what a great idea!!! I think they would be great for entertaining and for those days that you want a pumpkin pie without all the crazy baking!

  • hi! thanks SO much for sharing! where did you find/what size jars did you use?

  • God night:-)

    It looks very nice, I love it.
    Nice photos.
    Pumpkin, uhmmmmmmm!

    Mommy to: http://www.mariahoffbeck.blogspot.com

  • I’ll have to try making my pies this way now, if only to save myself from eating a whole one by myself. Of course, I’ll have to hide the rest from myself, and that could be a problem, but I love the concept of pie in a jar. Thanks for sharing this one.

  • Love these!! The best part is you can prepare these the night before; one less thing to make the day of.

    xoxo ~Shari

  • :O those are so PRECIOUS!!! Tiny pies in jars… Really? I could die of cuteness (and yumminess I’m so sure!)


  • What a great idea you guys, and so easy for any leftover pie to be taken home by guests!

    Maria xx

  • Cream cheese in pumpkin pie? I’m sold! Also, Elsie, where did you get that adorable sweater?

  • I love this idea! This is perfect for individual portions, especially at parties or events.


  • Yum, and darling!
    I also posted individual little pumpkin desserts today, but mine were total cheater no-bake style. 🙂
    Those jars are adorable.

  • I was thinking of making these this year. They really do seem more special to get your own.

  • These look so good! I love desserts in jars…there’s something about them that I just find so adorable and fun!

  • That looks amazing!!!!

    Love from Germany,

    Birdy and Bambi


  • I love making individual size dishes in jars! When I moved in to the dorms at college, a friend gave me a book of recipes for cooking deserts in jars, which was perfect for easy cooking in the dorm kitchen with my roommates!

  • I saw the first picture on instagram, and it made my day. I absolutely love everything in jars. Half of my christmas gifts this year will come in jars and it is my turn to bring desert for everyone christmas eve, and guess what after seeing this it is going to be a pie in a jar. <3

  • what a cute idea! maybe something for our christmas celebration 🙂
    xo, cheyenne

  • Loooove these! Great idea for Thanksgiving!

    BTW…what color/brand is your nail polish?

  • Yum those look delicious! I will have to try them when I visit home for Thanksgiving.


  • I really like this idea. Very hipster with the mason jars, lol.

    Whimsical Allure!

  • I love the pumpkin pies in a jar! I just made some last week for the first time as some thank you gifts and they were a huge hit (and delicious of course)!

  • Really good idea’s to put them in jars….a chocolate mousse would work well too!

  • This is the cutest idea! Love the creativity 🙂
    the way to my Hart

  • WOW! Thanks for this! My father-in-law asked for pumpkin pie at Thanksgiving. This looks amazing!

  • Pumpkin pie is my weakness. You can bet I’ll be making these for Thanksgiving!

  • Wow, looks good and it is a perfect recipe. I have now at home pumpkins so I ll try it.


  • Oh, what a fun, festive treat! Thanks so much for sharing 🙂


  • This looks super cool and customized. Thanks a lot for sharing this recipe.


  • That sounds like a yummy idea! How cute, and so much easier to serve!

    Monique, The Flair Society

  • It’s amazing this Friendsgivin, never ended!! I love your individual serving. Recentely I made as well one and I made an indivudual serving but different, if you want to take a look:

    Have a nice weekend!

  • These would be great as a vegan/gluten free option. Yum!
    xoxo Annejelina

  • So sweet! Planning on making these this weekend for company. Also, where is your sweater from? Too cute!

  • These look delicious and are so cute, it’s a great idea! I love when desserts are served as small individual servings.


  • SO obsessed! These are waaaay cute!

    xo, Juliette Laura

  • This looks sooooo delicious (the jars make it even more so!)


  • Where are those jars from? Would love to make these individual pies for thanksgiving!

  • Girls thank you for your ideas and publications. They inspire me a lot!!! I invite you to visit my blog www.elescaparatedemariana.com

  • I love pumpkin pie! A new fave of mine this year!! Love this!! 🙂

    Lulu xx


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.